History
Tu, 18 Feb, 2025

Sheffield
1 - 2
Carlton Town

Tu, 13 Aug, 2024

Carlton Town
1 - 1
Sheffield

Sa, 16 Dec, 2023

Sheffield
0 - 2
Carlton Town

Tu, 15 Aug, 2023

Carlton Town
2 - 1
Sheffield

Sa, 18 Feb, 2023

Sheffield
0 - 0
Carlton Town

Sa, 15 Oct, 2022

Carlton Town
2 - 4
Sheffield

Sa, 31 Oct, 2020

Sheffield
0 - 2
Carlton Town

Sa, 25 Jan, 2020

Sheffield
0 - 3
Carlton Town

Sa, 21 Sep, 2019

Carlton Town
2 - 2
Sheffield

Tu, 26 Mar, 2019

Sheffield
4 - 2
Carlton Town

Sa, 6 Oct, 2018

Carlton Town
0 - 1
Sheffield

Tu, 27 Mar, 2018

Sheffield
2 - 1
Carlton Town

Sa, 12 Aug, 2017

Carlton Town
2 - 0
Sheffield

Sa, 18 Mar, 2017

Sheffield
0 - 1
Carlton Town

Tu, 1 Nov, 2016

Carlton Town
1 - 3
Sheffield

Sa, 20 Feb, 2016

Carlton Town
2 - 0
Sheffield

Sa, 15 Aug, 2015

Sheffield
1 - 2
Carlton Town

Tu, 21 Apr, 2015

Sheffield
3 - 2
Carlton Town

Tu, 7 Oct, 2014

Carlton Town
1 - 4
Sheffield

Sa, 22 Feb, 2014

Sheffield
0 - 0
Carlton Town

Mo, 26 Aug, 2013

Carlton Town
1 - 0
Sheffield

Tu, 16 Apr, 2013

Sheffield
2 - 0
Carlton Town

Sa, 29 Sep, 2012

Carlton Town
2 - 2
Sheffield

Sa, 7 Apr, 2012

Carlton Town
3 - 1
Sheffield

Sa, 27 Aug, 2011

Sheffield
2 - 1
Carlton Town

Sa, 12 Feb, 2011

Sheffield
1 - 1
Carlton Town

Sa, 18 Sep, 2010

Carlton Town
2 - 0
Sheffield

Tu, 13 Apr, 2010

Sheffield
5 - 1
Carlton Town

Mo, 31 Aug, 2009

Carlton Town
2 - 0
Sheffield

Sa, 20 Dec, 2008

Carlton Town
3 - 3
Sheffield

Tu, 19 Aug, 2008

Sheffield
2 - 2
Carlton Town

Tu, 18 Mar, 2008

Sheffield
3 - 2
Carlton Town

Fr, 9 Nov, 2007

Carlton Town
4 - 1
Sheffield
